By Sarah Ladd
Kentucky Lantern
Franklin Circuit Judge Thomas Wingate has dismissed a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of a 2024 law banning the sale of some vaping products.
Wingate sided with the lawsuit’s defendants — Allyson Taylor, commissioner of the state Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, and Secretary of State Michael Adams — who filed a motion to dismiss. The law designates the ABC as its enforcement agency.
The Kentucky Smoke Free Association, which represents vape retailers, had argued that the law was too broad and arbitrary to be constitutional because it is titled “An act relating to nicotine products” but also mentions “other substances.” The state constitution says a law cannot relate to more than one subject.
In his opinion, Wingate said the law doesn’t violate the state constitution.
The law’s title “more than furnishes a clue to its contents and provides a general idea of the bill’s contents,” he wrote.
The law’s “reference to ‘other substances’ is not used in a manner outside of the context of the bill, but rather to logically indicate what is unauthorized,” Wingate wrote.
The lawsuit centers on House Bill 11, which passed during the 2024 legislative session and is scheduled to take effect Jan. 1. Its backers said it will curb underage vaping by limiting sales to “authorized products” or those that have “a safe harbor certification” based on their status with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.
Opponents have said it will hurt small businesses and favor big companies, and could drive youth to traditional cigarettes.
Altria, the parent company of tobacco giant Philip Morris, lobbied for the bill and is pushing similar bills in other states. Altria, which has moved aggressively into e-cigarette sales, markets multiple vaping products that have FDA approval.
“The sale of nicotine and vapor products are highly regulated in every state, and the court will not question the specific reasons for the General Assembly’s decision to regulate and limit the sale of nicotine and vapor products to only products approved by the FDA or granted a safe-harbor certification by the FDA,” Wingate wrote in a Monday opinion. “The regulation of these products directly relates to the health and safety of the commonwealth’s citizens, the power of which is vested by the Kentucky Constitution in the General Assembly.”
Tuesday, July 30, 2024
Home »
» State judge dismisses constitutional challenge to anti-vaping law
State judge dismisses constitutional challenge to anti-vaping law
Related Posts:
McConnell says to ignore 'demonstrably bad advice' from vaccine skeptics, and get vaccinated to control the pandemicBy Lisa Mascaro The Associated Press Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell implored unvaccinated Americans Tuesday to take a Covid-19 shot, issuing a stark and grave warning of a repeat of last year's shutdowns if pe… Read More
As cases, positive tests and hospitalizations rise, Beshear again recommends masking for the unvaccinated and some others State Department for Public Health graph, adapted by Kentucky Health News By Melissa Patrick Kentucky Health News Seeing acceleration of the coronavirus, driven by its highly contagious Delta variant, Gov. Andy Besh… Read More
State reports 1,054 new coronavirus cases, raising weekly infection rate by 18% in one day; state as a whole is 'orange' State Dept. for Public Health map, adapted by Kentucky Health News; to enlarge, click on it. By Al Cross Kentucky Health News If there was any doubt that the coronavirus is surging in Kentucky, it was dispelled by T… Read More
Kentucky reports 963 new coronavirus cases; its rate of increase over last the last two weeks, 256%, ranks 15th in the nation Screenshot of New York Times interactive map with seven-day new-case average; click to enlarge. By Al Cross Kentucky Health News The pandemic continued to resurge in Kentucky Tuesday, part of a national … Read More
Paul-Fauci feud escalates; they trade allegations of lying Dr. Anthony Fauci and Sen. Rand Paul faced off at a Senate committee hearing Tuesday. The long-running acrimony between U.S. Sen. Rand Paul and Dr. Anthony Fauci, head of the National Institute of Allergy and Infecti… Read More
0 comments:
Post a Comment